Friday, December 09, 2005

Resurrection, part 10

If there was any part of 1 Corinthians 15 that would cause me to change my mind, it’s the next part. In v. 45 it says, “So also it is written, ‘The first man, Adam, became a living soul.’ The last Adam became a life-giving spirit.” There you have it. Jesus became a spirit. That seems to settle it, doesn’t it? The problem is that it goes against everything else in the Bible. That makes me wonder if maybe there’s some other way to understand it. I think there is.

Let’s take this position to its logical conclusion. If the contrast is between material and immaterial, and if “spirit” refers to immaterial, then “soul” must refer to material. But that isn’t what “soul” refers to. Nowhere in the Bible does “soul” mean “material.” Soul either refers simply to any living person, or it refers to the immaterial aspect of our nature. When it refers to the immaterial aspect of our nature, then soul and spirit mean the same thing. But even God, who is spirit, is said to have a soul (see Leviticus 26:11).

I think Paul’s emphasis is more on the fact that Adam is “living” and Jesus is “life-giving.” It is because Jesus is a life-giving spirit that we will bear his image. He is the one who gives us life at the resurrection. The term, “spirit” need not refer to Jesus’ immateriality either. John uses the term “spirit” to refer to physical human beings (see 1 John 4:1-3), so “spirit” doesn’t strictly imply immateriality. But even if “spirit” does refer to Jesus’ immaterial nature, it doesn’t cause a problem. Jesus was spirit even before his death and resurrection, because he’s God. He has a dual nature. In fact, all humans have a dual nature. We are all spirits. Calling us spirits, then, does not mean we have no material nature. It certainly didn’t in John 4:1-3 when John referred to human beings as spirits.

to be continued... Part 11


At 8/05/2012 10:17 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

the soul does in fact refer to the immaterial aspect of OUR nature but in general the soul is that which gives form to matter.An animal or plant has a soul but is material(read:corruptible) and ceases to exist at the death of said life form. Humans,on the other hand have a soul that is spiritual( as part of our nature. Man is not dual natured ). In the strict sense spirit does mean immaterial by definition, although it is not always used that way.I may have explained this awfully so please read Aristotle's ''on the soul'' and especialy st. Thomas Aquinas (AKA the king of philosophy, theology and the higher sciences. One doesn't see him mentioned as often as he deserves.


Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home